Cannes Debuts Natalie Portman's Slow-Moving 'Story of Love and Darkness', Watching Portman act in familiar Hebrew is a somewhat of a delightful stun, such as seeing somebody you've known quite a while abruptly show that they can juggle blades
The best thing one can say in regards to Natalie Portman's directorial introduction, "A Tale of Love and Darkness" is that its not an inside and out fiasco.
Yet, unfortunately it feels like a vanity piece, showcasing the performing artist as a self-martyring Jewish mother, raising her especially refined, evacuee family on the cusp of Israel turning into a state in 1947.
Obviously its not consistently that a motion picture star – and a female one at that – puts herself hanging in the balance by composing and coordinating a genuine film. That is to be commended. What's more, viewing Portman act in familiar Hebrew is a somewhat of a delightful stun, such as seeing somebody you've known quite a while abruptly show that they can juggle blades, or walk a tightrope.
Yet, concerning coordinating, great that is another inquiry. "A Tale of Love and Darkness" begins as a story of the conception of Israel, told thoughtfully through a youthful Jewish family that has recently gotten away from the Holocaust in Europe. At that point it veers into a moderate moving story of a lady's drop into despondency, told from the viewpoint of her child (in light of the novel by Israeli author Amos Oz).
In a world populated by virtuoso executives including those at this celebration like Matteo Garrone (here with the psychedelic "Story of Tales"), Alejandro Innaritu or Portman's own "Dark Swan"-making Darren Aronofsky to give some examples, Portman's exertion feels liberal.
As the mother Fania, she gets an unreasonable measure of screen time lavishing Jewish nurturing love on her young child (who isn't that youthful, to be completely frank, to still be getting washed by Mama), making borscht and telling long, symbolic yarns.
What's more, the film will probably be scrutinized for its unvarnished sensitivity toward the Jewish perspective in the Israeli-Palestinian clash, which was deserving of more subtlety even in a story with Jewish protagnonists.
There's not an unsympathetic Jew in the whole story – everybody is continually perusing a book, or composing one – and in fact no scoundrel in the story by any stretch of the imagination, not even an Arab one. In one scene, the young man Amos meets a youthful Arab young lady at a get-together of an Arab family where Jews have been welcomed. Amos welcomes her in Arabic, the Arab young lady talks familiar Hebrew, and they talk about their goals to wind up artists and essayists. Discuss wish-satisfaction .
On the whole, the film appears to grasp Jewish generalizations without an insight of incongruity. The straightforwardness of the story may have conveyed the day, however rather there is little infiltration of the human condition to which viewers can interface, in spite of the preoccupation of Portman's continually shocking physical exc
The best thing one can say in regards to Natalie Portman's directorial introduction, "A Tale of Love and Darkness" is that its not an inside and out fiasco.
Yet, unfortunately it feels like a vanity piece, showcasing the performing artist as a self-martyring Jewish mother, raising her especially refined, evacuee family on the cusp of Israel turning into a state in 1947.
Obviously its not consistently that a motion picture star – and a female one at that – puts herself hanging in the balance by composing and coordinating a genuine film. That is to be commended. What's more, viewing Portman act in familiar Hebrew is a somewhat of a delightful stun, such as seeing somebody you've known quite a while abruptly show that they can juggle blades, or walk a tightrope.
Yet, concerning coordinating, great that is another inquiry. "A Tale of Love and Darkness" begins as a story of the conception of Israel, told thoughtfully through a youthful Jewish family that has recently gotten away from the Holocaust in Europe. At that point it veers into a moderate moving story of a lady's drop into despondency, told from the viewpoint of her child (in light of the novel by Israeli author Amos Oz).
In a world populated by virtuoso executives including those at this celebration like Matteo Garrone (here with the psychedelic "Story of Tales"), Alejandro Innaritu or Portman's own "Dark Swan"-making Darren Aronofsky to give some examples, Portman's exertion feels liberal.
As the mother Fania, she gets an unreasonable measure of screen time lavishing Jewish nurturing love on her young child (who isn't that youthful, to be completely frank, to still be getting washed by Mama), making borscht and telling long, symbolic yarns.
What's more, the film will probably be scrutinized for its unvarnished sensitivity toward the Jewish perspective in the Israeli-Palestinian clash, which was deserving of more subtlety even in a story with Jewish protagnonists.
There's not an unsympathetic Jew in the whole story – everybody is continually perusing a book, or composing one – and in fact no scoundrel in the story by any stretch of the imagination, not even an Arab one. In one scene, the young man Amos meets a youthful Arab young lady at a get-together of an Arab family where Jews have been welcomed. Amos welcomes her in Arabic, the Arab young lady talks familiar Hebrew, and they talk about their goals to wind up artists and essayists. Discuss wish-satisfaction .
On the whole, the film appears to grasp Jewish generalizations without an insight of incongruity. The straightforwardness of the story may have conveyed the day, however rather there is little infiltration of the human condition to which viewers can interface, in spite of the preoccupation of Portman's continually shocking physical exc
Blogger Comment
Facebook Comment